Technology at School:  An exploratory project on teacher roles when new teaching tools are introduced to the classroom

Auch auf Deutsch verfügbar

This project explores how teachers in Switzerland have approached new technologies in the past and questions whether this widely held theory can be supported or whether it should be reconsidered.

Content of this page

Profile

Project leadership
Michael Geiss (PHZH)
Project team
Jeannine Erb
Organisational unit
F-BW-BDW (Bildung und Digitaler Wandel)
Project phase
Completed (1.9.2021 – 31.8.2022)
Project type
Research & development project
Funding
Stiftung Pestalozzianum

Description

A considerable amount of research takes a historical view of the discussion, implementation and use of new teaching technologies. In these studies, teachers are often cast as being biased against new technologies and unwilling to use innovative tools in the classroom. In this research project, the theory that teachers tend to reject technological innovations that have been imposed from above is critically examined. Particular attention is paid to the ways in which teachers have strategically positioned themselves in the past – as individual experts and in the context of teacher associations – when new technologies have been introduced to the classroom. What roles have teachers played in the discussions and in the (un-)successful implementation of technology in the classroom? How have they organised their resistance and how have they expressed critical opinions?

Two historical examples serve to identify the positions and attitudes of teachers in Switzerland. In the first example, teacher input when audio-visual media were introduced to schools is explored. The second example reconstructs the role teachers played when computers entered the classroom, first in the form of workstations and large computers , then later as microcomputers.

The time period under investigation in both examples is the second half of the 20th century. The collections in the foundation Stiftung Pestalozzianum provide the data for the historical reconstruction of teacher positions and attitudes towards technological change in the Swiss educational system. In addition, press material from pedagogical journals and teacher associations, topic-specific brochures and pedagogical manuals on the various new teaching technologies are analysed. Holdings from other archives (such as the Wymann Archives) as well as documentation of professional pedagogical debate (for instance, reports on the negotiations held in the Zurich school assembly ) are also examined to ascertain the degree to which the widely held theory of teacher resistance to technology can be supported or whether it should be reconsidered.

Project outcomes

The aim of this historical research project was to better understand the role that teachers have traditionally played in the development and implementation of new teaching media. The project was designed as an exploratory study; the focus was placed on the second half of the 20th century.

In the past, teachers in Switzerland have been involved in the development, preparation and implementation of new teaching media in multiple ways, as demonstrated in an analysis of the historical holdings at the Pestalozzianum research library and the archives of the Swiss Teachers’ Association. In the context of the project, an article in English was published and a follow-up proposal for a larger historical research project submitted.

Teachers and new media

Historical educational research has long held that teachers are fundamentally critical of new teaching technologies. In more recent research, however, this purported technological bias among teachers has been questioned. These findings served as the starting point for the exploratory research project, which was funded by the foundation Stiftung Pestalozzianum. Of the course of the study, it became apparent that teachers in Switzerland have played an active part in the development, introduction and dissemination of new teaching media in the classroom.

A historical perspective

At the start of the project, holdings at the Pestalozzianum research library were examined to establish the degree to which various educational stakeholders in Switzerland were involved with new teaching media and what role audiovisual media played therein. In a second step, the researchers studied press material from pedagogical journals in Switzerland, which are accessible at the Pestalozzianum research library and the open-access platform E-Periodica. During this project phase, the predecessor organisation of the Swiss Teachers Association emerged as a particularly interesting subject; to further investigate, the Association’s private archives were consulted.

Contact

Portrait photo of Prof. Dr. Michael Geiss

+41 43 305 54 73