PICTS in an Evolving Digital Society: Needs and demands
Auch auf Deutsch verfügbar
Content of this page
Profile
- Project leadership
- Michael Geiss (PHZH), Tobias Röhl (PHZH, former employee)
- Organisational unit
- F-BW-BDW (Bildung und Digitaler Wandel)
- Project phase
- Completed (1.12.2021 – 31.5.2022)
- Project type
- Research & development project
- Funding
- Bildungsdirektion Kanton Zürich, Volksschulamt, Fachstelle Bildung und ICT
Description
At compulsory schools in the Canton of Zurich, PICTS (Pedagogical ICT Support Staff) have a vital role in the digital transformation. As experts for integrated ICT, media literacy education and computer science, they support teachers and school directors. Their work therefore encompasses key planning and developmental tasks, and PICTS staff are active in an advisory capacity and in professional development. Moreover, they keep pace with current technical and media innovations and consider the impact these developments have for school education.
Since the PICTS – Pedagogical ICT Support education programme was first offered in 2007, the professional role of these experts has continually evolved. For this reason, the current project investigates the changed professional conditions for PICTS staff and seeks possibilities at various levels (schools, educational authorities, professional development programmes) to optimally support these specialists in carrying out their work. From a methodological point of view, the project draws on analyses of documents from the fields of professional development and education policy as well as qualitative interviews with PICT staff and work in focus groups consisting of various persons involved at schools.
Project outcomes
The activities of pedagogical ICT support (PICTS) staff differ from school district to school district – even from school to school. The differences concern the division of roles as well as the working conditions for pedagogical ICT support. PICTS staff take on pedagogical as well as technical and organisational tasks; in terms of pedagogy, they help schools in attaining a meaningful use of digital media, develop products, advise colleagues, offer further training, and support the teaching staff in the classroom. Often the work of PICTS staff is convincing other teachers of the benefits of digital media and lowering their resistance to using digital tools. They also provide technical support, either because this is part of their job description or because technical issues must be solved before they can begin with their actual work. The difficulty in differentiating between these two areas of responsibility was frequently mentioned in the interviews. The organisational tasks of PICTS staff include developing concepts and advising on the selection and purchase of equipment.
PICTS staff are situated at the interface between various types of roles in education. They are the main point of contact for other teachers, but they must also occasionally align their work with principals, school boards, public authorities, technical ICT support staff and other stakeholders. In the interviews, it became apparent that PICTS staff greatly appreciate the open exchange with these individuals, both at school and outside the school setting. Ideally, they also maintain personal contact with educational authorities and thus receive relevant information while also ensuring that their perspective is considered when important decisions in education policy are made in communes and the canton.
The specific employment context of PICTS staff determines their working conditions and how they carry out their mission. In large, urban communes, they are part of a defined hierarchy of jobs and generally have clear guidelines concerning their responsibilities and the infrastructure they can work with. In small communes, by contrast, their ability to carry out their responsibilities relies much more strongly on the support offered by principals and the school board, the financial situation of the commune, the specific job requirements, the organisation of technical ICT support and the culture that has been cultivated at the individual schools. The extent to which the other teachers are motivated and interested in using digital media is also a fundamental factor that should be given due attention.
In the interviews, PICTS staff expressed clear wishes where they see a need for change. Firstly, they cited the urgent need for clearly defined responsibilities at schools, so that all involved understand what they are required (or not required) to do. In this context, the pedagogical aspect of their work is evidently at the heart of their self-image; they also place value on the division of labour with other roles within a school district. Secondly, they pointed out the importance that policy makers and public authorities design clear future scenarios for the direction in which pedagogical ICT support should be further developed. Thirdly, they were adamant in saying that securing financial and material resources at schools is not enough for successful PICTS work; it is also critical that they be given enough working hours to concentrate on a project or concern for a longer period of time. For this, the financial commitment of the communes and authorities is decisive. Fourthly, there are technical settings that must be made widely accessible to facilitate the work of PICTS staff; this includes secure cloud solutions or single sign-on (SSO) procedures. In the interviews, a desire for a certain level of technical standardisation was also expressed.
PICTS staff are key players in achieving the digital transformation at compulsory schools. Their work in the classroom is highly diverse, ranging from technical support to demanding pedagogical and organisational tasks. In their day-to-day activities at schools and in collaboration with various other education professionals, they realise the goals set by researchers, education policy makers and principals – while also contributing their own ideas. In the process, they are confronted with diverse technological developments, social and economic interests, not to mention political expectations. These factors must be adequately addressed at schools, in education policy and when designing professional development courses at universities of teacher education. In addition to providing the requisite resources and scope for action, it is also important that PICTS assignments are clearly defined, and that PICTS staff are given the necessary authority to carry out their tasks. Only then can they realise their potential as advocates of a digital transformation that is educationally sustainable.